Analyzing The Epic Conclusion: The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies

Axel S�rensen

4 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.7

Share

Narrative Structure and Pacing

The final act of The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies presents a complex tapestry of interwoven storylines. The film attempts to resolve multiple plot threads simultaneously: Thorin's desperate fight for Erebor, the growing conflict between the dwarves, elves, men, and the goblin hordes, and Bilbo's own internal struggle. This ambitious undertaking, while visually impressive, raises questions about pacing.

• Rushed Resolution?: Certain character arcs, particularly those outside Thorin's, feel somewhat rushed to make way for the massive battle sequence. The urgency of the situation is palpable, but some might argue that sacrificing character depth for spectacle weakens the overall narrative.
• Interweaving Storylines: The film successfully weaves together the various narratives, cleverly using the battle as a catalyst for confrontation and resolution. The confrontation between Thorin and Bard, for instance, is a powerful moment directly tied to the battle's outcome.
• Plot Inconsistencies: Some minor plot inconsistencies, such as the relatively swift defeat of certain antagonists, might leave viewers wanting a more satisfying level of conflict. The sheer scale of the battle, however, often overshadows these smaller issues.

The Visual Spectacle of the Five Armies Battle

The battle of five armies is undeniably the film's centerpiece. The visual effects are breathtaking, achieving an unprecedented level of scale and detail for a fantasy battle sequence. The sheer number of combatants, the stunning environments, and the innovative use of CGI all contribute to an unforgettable cinematic experience.

• Masterful CGI: The CGI is seamlessly integrated, creating a realistic and immersive world where armies clash in a chaotic ballet of swordplay, magic, and destruction.
• Cinematic Brilliance: The cinematography captures the scale and intensity of the battle brilliantly, utilizing sweeping camera movements and dynamic angles to emphasize the chaotic nature of the conflict.
• Immersive Soundscape: The sound design further enhances the experience, creating a powerful and immersive soundscape that perfectly complements the visual spectacle. The roar of the battle, the clash of steel, and the cries of the combatants all contribute to the film's epic feel. This can be favorably compared to other large-scale battles in fantasy films like Lord of the Rings, although the style and technology differ significantly.

Character Development and Arcs in the Conclusion

The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies provides resolution for several key character arcs. Thorin Oakenshield’s journey is arguably the most significant. His transformation from a greedy, obsessive dwarf to a courageous, self-sacrificing leader is a compelling narrative arc, although some might find the speed of his redemption slightly abrupt.

• Thorin's Redemption: The film delivers a satisfying, albeit somewhat rushed, conclusion to Thorin's arc. His final moments are poignant and emotionally resonant, successfully communicating the weight of his past actions and the cost of his redemption.
• Bilbo's Growth: Bilbo Baggins' journey mirrors Thorin's in some ways. His experiences during the quest and the battle solidify his character and give him a newfound appreciation for courage and self-worth.
• Supporting Characters: Other characters, such as Bard and Gandalf, also experience substantial growth and development. Their involvement in the battle shapes their futures and strengthens their relationships with other characters.

Faithfulness to Tolkien's Source Material

While The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies draws inspiration from Tolkien's The Hobbit, it takes considerable creative liberties. The film expands upon the source material, adding new characters, storylines, and extending the scale of the battle significantly.

• Expanded Narrative: The film's narrative significantly expands upon the concise account of the battle found in the book. While this adds excitement and depth to certain characters, it also deviates from the original story.
• Character Alterations: Several characters undergo significant transformations compared to their book counterparts, both in terms of personality and importance to the narrative.
• Spirit of Tolkien: Despite its alterations, the film largely captures the spirit and themes of Tolkien's work – themes of courage, friendship, and the importance of fighting for what is right.

A Final Look at The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies' Conclusion

In conclusion, The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies delivers a visually spectacular and narratively ambitious conclusion. While its pacing and faithfulness to the source material might be points of contention, the film undeniably delivers an unforgettable cinematic experience. The battle sequence itself is a masterpiece of visual effects and sound design, and the character arcs, though sometimes rushed, ultimately provide satisfying resolutions. The effectiveness of the conclusion depends heavily on individual priorities—spectacle versus narrative depth.

What are your thoughts on the epic conclusion of The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies? Share your analysis in the comments below!