Costly Mistakes? Jaap Stam Assesses Ten Hag's Impact On Man United

Axel S�rensen

5 min read

Post on May 23, 2025

4.1

Share

Jaap Stam, a former Manchester United stalwart known for his uncompromising style and tactical acumen, brings unparalleled credibility to this assessment. His experience as a top-level player and his insightful commentary on modern football establish him as a trusted voice on managerial strategies and their impact. This article aims to delve into Ten Hag's impact on Manchester United, analyzing his tactical approach, player recruitment, and overall management, all through the prism of Stam's expert opinions to determine whether any costly mistakes have been made.

Ten Hag's Tactical Approach: Strengths and Weaknesses

Ten Hag's tactical imprint on Manchester United is undeniable. His emphasis on a possession-based, high-pressing style has yielded positive results, but also reveals areas needing refinement.

Positive Aspects:

• Improved Defensive Solidity: Ten Hag implemented a more disciplined defensive structure, significantly reducing the number of goals conceded compared to previous seasons. His emphasis on tactical improvements in the backline, coupled with the arrival of Casemiro, has led to increased defensive stability. The clean sheets against strong opposition are testament to this.
• Effective Pressing Strategies: The high press, a hallmark of Ten Hag's style, has disrupted opponents' build-up play and created numerous turnovers, leading to scoring opportunities. We saw the effectiveness of this pressing game in matches against Liverpool and Arsenal.
• Player Development Under Ten Hag: Players like Marcus Rashford have experienced a significant resurgence under Ten Hag's tutelage, showcasing the manager's ability to nurture and develop existing talent. The improved form of several players highlights Ten Hag's positive impact on player development.

Areas for Improvement:

• Vulnerability to Counter-Attacks: Despite the improved defense, Manchester United has at times remained vulnerable to swift counter-attacks, exposing a weakness in transition. The loss against Brighton early in the season highlighted this tactical weakness.
• Creative Struggles in Certain Games: While the high press works effectively, there have been instances where Manchester United's attacking play has lacked creativity, particularly against well-organized defenses. This squad rotation strategy and player selection occasionally impacted the team’s fluidity.
• Inconsistency in Squad Rotation Strategy: The effectiveness of Ten Hag's squad rotation has been debated, with some suggesting that inconsistent player selection has hampered the team's consistency. This was evident in some of the cup matches.

Player Recruitment and Management: Hits and Misses

Ten Hag's impact is also reflected in his player recruitment and management strategies. While some signings have been resounding successes, others have raised questions.

Successful Signings:

• Casemiro's Transformative Influence: The arrival of Casemiro has been pivotal, providing defensive solidity and leadership in midfield. His impact on both the defensive and offensive phases of play has been undeniably transformative.
• Emergence of Young Talents: Ten Hag has shown a willingness to promote young players, offering opportunities to develop their skills and contribute to the first team. This showcases his ability to nurture young talents within the team.

Questionable Transfers and Player Usage:

• Underperforming Players: Certain players acquired have not lived up to expectations, raising questions about the recruitment process. This highlights potential issues in player management issues and future transfer strategies.
• Underutilized Players: Some established players have seen limited game time, leading to speculation about squad balance and player management. This inconsistent player usage can sometimes impact team morale.

The Impact of Injuries and Squad Depth

Injuries have undeniably hampered Ten Hag's ability to consistently implement his tactical plans. The lack of squad depth in certain positions has often forced him to adapt his strategy, sometimes compromising his preferred style of play. Key injuries to Rashford, Martinez and others have severely tested the resilience of the squad.

Jaap Stam's Overall Assessment and Predictions

Jaap Stam's overall assessment is likely to be nuanced. While acknowledging the significant progress made under Ten Hag, he's likely to highlight the need to address the tactical weaknesses and recruitment issues to build a truly sustainable and competitive team. His insights would likely focus on the importance of consistent squad rotation, addressing vulnerability to counter-attacks, and ensuring depth across all positions. His predictions may involve suggestions for strengthening the squad during the transfer window and refining tactical approaches to mitigate the weaknesses.

Costly Mistakes? A Final Verdict on Ten Hag's Impact

Erik ten Hag's tenure at Manchester United has been marked by both significant progress and potential costly mistakes. While his tactical innovations, particularly the improved defensive solidity and the emergence of young talents, are commendable, the vulnerability to counter-attacks and inconsistent squad rotation remain concerns. Jaap Stam's assessment, emphasizing the need to address these weaknesses, provides a valuable perspective. The success of Ten Hag's project hinges on addressing these challenges to build a truly dominant team.

What are your thoughts on Erik ten Hag's management of Manchester United? Do you agree with a potential assessment from Jaap Stam highlighting costly mistakes? Share your views in the comments section below! Let's discuss the future of Man United under Ten Hag and how to avoid costly mistakes moving forward.