Did Captain America: Brave New World Leave Out A Key Player For Future MCU Franchises?

Axel S�rensen

4 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.8

Share

The Significance of Sharon Carter in the Comics and Previous MCU Appearances

Sharon Carter, niece of Peggy Carter and a key player in the Marvel comics, has a rich history intertwined with Captain America himself. Her MCU appearances, beginning in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, established her as a complex character with a compelling backstory and potential for significant growth.

• Key storylines in the comics: Sharon's involvement in significant Captain America storylines, her own struggles with identity, and her complex relationship with Steve Rogers make her a potent figure in the Marvel universe. Her strategic mind and covert operations experience makes her a valuable asset.
• Established MCU role: Her established connections to the MCU's past and her ambiguous morality, revealed in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, create considerable narrative potential. She possesses a deep understanding of espionage and covert operations, making her a valuable asset within the larger MCU tapestry.
• Potential for Growth: The MCU has only scratched the surface of Sharon Carter's potential. Her journey could have explored themes of redemption, power, and the complexities of morality within a world of superpowered individuals. Her position as Power Broker hints at a much larger and darker role that could dramatically impact future stories. The possibilities are plentiful for a character with so much unexplored potential.

How Sharon Carter's Absence Impacts Potential Storylines

Sharon Carter's absence from Captain America: Brave New World creates noticeable narrative gaps and missed opportunities for compelling storylines. Her omission significantly impacts the potential development of several key areas:

• Missed Opportunities for Character Interaction: Sharon's established history with Steve Rogers and her connections to other key players, such as Sam Wilson and Bucky Barnes, would have enriched the film's narrative. Her interactions could have added depth and complexity to the characters already present.
• Impact on the Plot: The film's narrative involving the new Captain America could have significantly benefitted from the strategic mind and covert operations experience of Sharon Carter. Her expertise in espionage could have provided essential insights and resources.
• Unresolved Narrative Threads: The Falcon and the Winter Soldier left many questions about Sharon’s future and her ambiguous moral compass. Brave New World missed the chance to address these vital threads and further develop her character arc.
  • Specific examples: Her role as Power Broker could have been further explored, creating conflict and adding layers of intrigue to the film. The consequences of her actions and her interactions with other characters would have enhanced the storyline.

Speculation on Future Appearances and Narrative Solutions

While absent from Brave New World, Sharon Carter's future within the MCU remains a possibility. Several scenarios could incorporate her return:

• Future Films: She could appear in future films featuring Sam Wilson, Bucky Barnes, or other characters connected to her past. A direct sequel to The Falcon and the Winter Soldier could also provide an ideal platform for her return and story resolution.
• Explanations for Absence: Her absence in Brave New World could be explained by various narrative devices, such as covert missions or deliberate strategic choices made by the writers, thus creating further intrigue for her potential comeback.
• Alternative Narrative Solutions: The MCU could still resolve her storyline through flashbacks, brief cameo appearances, or through mentions in other projects.

Comparing Sharon Carter's Role to Other Key Players in the MCU

Sharon Carter's potential contribution to the MCU is comparable to that of other influential characters. Her strategic acumen and understanding of espionage, much like Nick Fury's, could prove indispensable in future storylines. Comparing her potential role to other supporting characters, such as Maria Hill, highlights the missed opportunity to leverage her expertise in shaping the MCU narrative.

• Key Attributes and Contributions: Her blend of intelligence, experience, and ambiguous morality make her a unique asset, comparable to the contributions of other key players in the MCU. She could have served as a critical link between various factions and storylines.
• Impact of Similar Absences: While not identical, the absence of significant supporting characters in previous MCU films has, at times, impacted the narrative flow and overall coherence of the story. Sharon's absence from Brave New World echoes a similar potential downside.

Conclusion: The Unseen Potential of Sharon Carter in the Future of the MCU

The absence of Sharon Carter from Captain America: Brave New World represents a missed opportunity to leverage a compelling character with a complex backstory and immense narrative potential. Her omission creates narrative gaps and weakens potential storylines within the wider MCU. Her expertise in espionage, strategic thinking, and her history with key characters within the MCU would have added depth and complexity to the film and future installments. Do you think Sharon Carter is a crucial missing piece in the MCU's future? Share your thoughts in the comments below!