Indonesia's Potential Ties With Israel: Contingent On Palestine Recognition

Axel S�rensen

5 min read

Post on May 29, 2025

4.0

Share

Economic Advantages of Closer Indonesia-Israel Relations

Closer ties between Indonesia and Israel hold significant economic promise. The potential for collaboration and mutual benefit across various sectors is substantial.

Technological Collaboration

Indonesia could significantly benefit from Israel's advanced technologies in several key areas. Israel is a global leader in agriculture, water management, and cybersecurity – sectors where Indonesia seeks significant improvements.

• Joint ventures: Establishing collaborative projects in these fields could lead to rapid technological advancement in Indonesia.
• Technology transfer: Israel's expertise could be transferred to Indonesian counterparts, fostering local innovation and capacity building.
• Increased agricultural productivity: Israel's pioneering work in desert agriculture, utilizing drip irrigation and precision farming techniques, could significantly boost Indonesian agricultural yields, addressing food security challenges.
• Improved national security: Collaboration on cybersecurity is crucial in today's digital age, protecting Indonesia's critical infrastructure and data from increasingly sophisticated cyber threats.

Israel's expertise in desert agriculture, particularly relevant to arid and semi-arid regions of Indonesia, could revolutionize farming practices and contribute to food security. Similarly, collaboration on cybersecurity is critical given the rising number of cyberattacks globally. Improved agricultural techniques and enhanced cybersecurity are paramount to Indonesia's national development.

Trade and Investment Opportunities

Increased trade and investment flows would mutually benefit both economies. This enhanced economic partnership would unlock considerable potential.

• Increased exports of Indonesian commodities: Indonesian exports of palm oil, coffee, rubber, and other commodities could experience significant growth in the Israeli market.
• Israeli investments in Indonesian infrastructure: Israel's private sector, known for its innovation and efficiency, could play a crucial role in developing Indonesia's infrastructure projects.
• Creation of jobs: Increased trade and investment would create numerous job opportunities in Indonesia, stimulating economic growth and reducing unemployment.

Israel's strong private sector could contribute significantly to Indonesia's economic growth through Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), particularly in infrastructure development and technology sectors. This influx of investment could help accelerate Indonesia's economic development and improve its global competitiveness.

Political and Strategic Considerations

While the economic benefits are substantial, significant political and strategic considerations must be carefully weighed. The Palestine issue looms large, significantly impacting the dynamics of potential relations.

The Palestine Issue as a Major Hurdle

Indonesia's unwavering support for the Palestinian cause and the two-state solution presents a major obstacle to normalizing relations with Israel. Public opinion in Indonesia overwhelmingly favors Palestinian rights.

• Potential domestic political backlash: Any perceived shift towards closer ties with Israel could lead to significant domestic political opposition and social unrest.
• Pressure from regional allies: Indonesia’s position within the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) and its relationship with other Muslim-majority nations would heavily influence its stance.
• Maintaining the status quo: The existing cautious approach reflects the sensitivity surrounding this issue and the need to manage potential risks.

Indonesia's commitment to the two-state solution and its role within the OIC are deeply entrenched in its foreign policy, making any significant change in its Israel policy a complex undertaking.

Regional Geopolitics

The broader regional context and Indonesia's relationships with other Arab and Muslim countries play a vital role in shaping its foreign policy toward Israel.

• Balancing relationships with key regional players: Indonesia must carefully navigate its relationships with various regional actors to avoid jeopardizing its existing alliances.
• Potential impact on Indonesia's standing within the OIC: Any significant shift in Indonesia's policy towards Israel could impact its standing and influence within the OIC.
• Implications for regional stability: A significant change in Indonesia's approach could have unforeseen consequences for regional stability and security.

Navigating these complex regional dynamics requires careful consideration and strategic planning. Indonesia's actions must be calibrated to minimize potential negative impacts on its regional standing and relationships.

Potential Pathways to Improved Relations

Despite the challenges, pathways exist to gradually improve relations between Indonesia and Israel. A measured approach, focused on areas of mutual benefit and trust-building, is crucial.

Incremental Engagement

A phased approach focusing on non-political areas can help build a foundation for future cooperation.

• Track-two diplomacy: Informal discussions and collaborations between non-governmental organizations and experts can help bridge the gap and foster understanding.
• Academic exchanges: Increased collaboration between universities and research institutions can facilitate the exchange of knowledge and expertise.
• Cultural collaborations: Promoting people-to-people exchanges through cultural events and artistic collaborations can help build bridges between the two societies.

Building trust and understanding through people-to-people exchanges and collaborative projects can create a more favorable climate for future political engagement.

Conditional Recognition

Indonesia might consider recognizing Israel conditionally, linking such recognition to progress towards a two-state solution and the establishment of a Palestinian state.

• Setting clear benchmarks for Israeli actions: Indonesia could articulate specific conditions and benchmarks related to Israeli actions on the ground.
• Linking recognition to concrete steps towards peace: Formal recognition would be contingent on demonstrable progress towards a peaceful resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

This conditional approach could help to address the concerns of Indonesia’s populace while simultaneously opening the door for stronger ties with Israel.

Conclusion

The potential for stronger Indonesia-Israel relations is undeniable, offering substantial economic and technological benefits for both nations. However, Indonesia’s unwavering support for Palestine and the need for a just and lasting resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict remain paramount. A gradual, conditional approach, prioritizing the two-state solution and clear benchmarks for progress, could potentially bridge the divide and unlock the significant mutual benefits inherent in improved Indonesia-Israel relations. Further research and open public dialogue on Indonesia-Israel relations, considering both the opportunities and challenges, are essential to effectively navigate this complex issue.