Lumon Industries Vs. Apple: Ben Stiller's Severance And Corporate Culture

Axel S�rensen

4 min read

Post on May 17, 2025

4.4

Share

Lumon Industries: A Dystopian Reflection of Modern Corporate Practices

Lumon Industries, the enigmatic corporation at the heart of Severance, represents a dystopian exaggeration of certain aspects of modern corporate practices. Its unsettling methods serve as a potent critique of unchecked power and the potential for technological manipulation within the workplace.

The Severance Procedure and its implications:

The "severance" procedure itself is the central horror of the show. Employees undergo a surgical procedure that literally separates their work and personal memories. This has profound psychological ramifications:

• Fragmented identity: Individuals lead completely separate lives, unaware of their actions and experiences in the "outie" (personal life) while at work ("innie").
• Ethical breaches: The procedure raises profound ethical questions about consent, autonomy, and the exploitation of vulnerable workers.
• Power imbalance: The power dynamic between Lumon's management and its employees is profoundly skewed. Employees are essentially controlled puppets, with their innie selves completely subjugated to the company's will. This speaks to a broader concern about corporate control and the potential for exploitation in the modern workplace.

Lumon's Surveillance State and Control:

Lumon operates under a pervasive surveillance state. Every aspect of employee behavior is monitored and controlled:

• Constant observation: Cameras, sensors, and other technological tools monitor employee actions within the office.
• Information control: The flow of information is strictly controlled, with employees only privy to information deemed necessary by management.
• Enforcement of conformity: Through subtle and overt methods, Lumon enforces strict conformity, stifling individuality and independent thought. This use of technology to enforce conformity highlights concerns about the potential for corporate overreach in a technologically advanced world.

The "Overtime Contingency" and its exploitation:

The "Overtime Contingency" showcases the lengths to which Lumon will go to exploit its employees:

• Blurred lines: The concept blurs the lines between work and personal life even further, pushing employees beyond their limits.
• Ethical violation: The inherent exploitation involved in forcing employees to work beyond the boundaries of their contract raises serious ethical concerns regarding workplace standards.
• Lack of boundaries: The inability of the "innies" to refuse or even comprehend the extended work hours exemplifies the ultimate erosion of employee rights and autonomy.

Apple: A Real-World Counterpoint to Lumon's Extreme Practices

While Apple is far from a dystopian nightmare like Lumon Industries, examining its corporate culture provides a valuable counterpoint and reveals intriguing parallels.

Apple's highly structured corporate culture:

Apple is renowned for its emphasis on secrecy, innovation, and a highly structured work environment:

• Rigorous hiring: Apple's rigorous hiring processes and high employee expectations cultivate a culture of intense focus and dedication.
• Strong benefits: The company is known for offering strong employee benefits, including competitive salaries and comprehensive health plans.
• Career opportunities: Apple provides significant career opportunities for talented individuals, creating a culture of ambition and professional growth.

Criticisms of Apple's corporate culture:

Despite its positive aspects, Apple's corporate culture has faced criticism:

• Intense work environment: Reports of intense work pressure, long hours, and demanding deadlines are common.
• Compensation concerns: Some employees have voiced concerns regarding compensation, particularly for entry-level or support roles.
• Employee burnout: The demanding nature of Apple's work has been linked to cases of employee burnout and dissatisfaction.

Drawing parallels and contrasts with Lumon:

Comparing Lumon and Apple highlights significant differences, but some parallels exist:

• Control mechanisms: Both entities employ control mechanisms, but Apple’s are less overt and manipulative than Lumon’s.
• Employee well-being: While Apple offers benefits, the pressure to perform can negatively impact employee well-being, echoing some of the problems seen in Lumon, albeit to a far lesser degree.
• Corporate responsibility: Apple's approach to corporate social responsibility is a point of ongoing debate, while Lumon shows a blatant disregard for its employees' well-being.

Conclusion: Lumon Industries, Apple, and the Future of Work

The comparison between Lumon Industries and Apple reveals a spectrum of corporate cultures, ranging from dystopian exploitation to a more nuanced reality of high pressure and achievement. Severance offers a powerful commentary on modern workplace dynamics, forcing us to confront uncomfortable truths about corporate power, surveillance, and the potential for exploitation. Both fictional and real-world examples highlight the ethical considerations inherent in shaping a work environment that values both productivity and employee well-being. Understanding the stark contrast between Lumon Industries and Apple allows us to critically examine our own workplaces and consider the implications of unchecked corporate power. Dive deeper into the unsettling world of Severance and start a conversation about building a more ethical and humane corporate culture.