Should John Wick 5 Be Made? Exploring The Arguments Against

Axel S�rensen

5 min read

Post on May 07, 2025

4.8

Share

Diminishing Returns and Creative Fatigue

The risk of creative stagnation is ever-present in long-running franchises. Repeated storylines and action sequences, no matter how expertly executed, can lead to audience fatigue. The magic of the John Wick films lies partly in their innovative approach to action choreography and storytelling. However, replicating this success repeatedly is a significant challenge.

• Over-reliance on familiar tropes: Continuing to rely on the same fighting styles, weapons, and narrative structures could diminish the impact of future John Wick films. The thrill of the unexpected is a key component of the franchise’s success.
• Formulaic action choreography: The innovative action choreography that defined the earlier films might become formulaic if John Wick 5 attempts to simply rehash previous successes. Audiences crave originality and fresh ideas.
• Pushing John Wick beyond his limits: Pushing the character of John Wick beyond his physical and emotional limits could negatively impact his believability. The audience’s connection to the character relies, in part, on his resilience and near-mythical status. Over-extending this could damage that carefully cultivated image.

The sheer physical demands placed on Keanu Reeves, who is now in his late 50s, also needs to be considered. A decline in the quality of the action sequences, due to physical limitations, would undoubtedly damage the overall franchise reputation and could negatively impact future John Wick films.

The Narrative's Natural Conclusion

John Wick 4 provided a seemingly satisfying conclusion to John Wick's arc. The film delivered a potent emotional resonance, leaving the audience with a sense of closure. A fifth film could risk undermining this established closure, potentially leaving fans feeling dissatisfied.

• A clear emotional resolution: The ending of John Wick 4 presented a clear emotional resolution for the character, allowing for a sense of finality. A sequel might feel like unnecessary exploitation of a well-told story.
• Contrived continuation: Forcing a continuation might feel contrived and unnecessary to loyal fans, who may appreciate the established narrative conclusion. The integrity of the storyline is paramount.
• Diluting the narrative: Introducing a new antagonist or storyline risks diluting the impact of the established narrative. The focus should remain on the core character and his journey.

A focus on sequels over a satisfying conclusion to the original story can create a sense of fan dissatisfaction. The emotional resonance of the previous films, a significant part of their success, could be jeopardized by a poorly executed sequel.

Financial Risks and Box Office Performance

While the John Wick franchise has been financially successful, a fifth film carries inherent financial risks. The law of diminishing returns applies to box office success; each subsequent film typically earns less than its predecessor.

• Diminishing box office returns: The box office success of each film is progressively less than the previous. A fifth film is unlikely to match the success of the previous installments.
• High production costs: Production costs for action-heavy films are consistently high, potentially leading to a lower return on investment for John Wick 5. This financial risk should be carefully assessed.
• Negative critical reception: Negative critical reception for John Wick 5 could damage the franchise's overall brand value, potentially impacting the potential success of future spin-offs and related projects.

A potential box office flop could discourage future investments in the franchise and negatively impact the profitability of the entire series. This risk makes the decision to produce John Wick 5 a high-stakes gamble.

Alternative Approaches: Spin-offs and Expanding the Universe

Instead of a direct sequel, exploring the John Wick universe through spin-offs (like Ballerina) offers a safer and potentially more creative avenue. This strategy allows for the franchise to continue expanding without relying on the continued presence of Keanu Reeves and the risk of diminishing returns associated with a direct sequel.

• New storylines and characters: Spin-offs allow for new storylines and characters while maintaining the established world, providing opportunities for fresh narratives and action sequences.
• Minimizing risks: Spin-offs minimize the risk of damaging the core character of John Wick, ensuring the integrity of the original storyline and character development.
• Attracting new audiences: Spin-offs can attract new audiences and extend the longevity of the franchise without the pressure of a direct sequel, providing a long-term growth strategy for the franchise.

Conclusion

While the allure of another John Wick adventure is strong, the potential risks associated with John Wick 5 warrant careful consideration. The possibility of diminishing returns, narrative exhaustion, and financial losses suggests that exploring alternative avenues, such as spin-offs and expanding the already rich John Wick universe, may be a more prudent strategy for the franchise's future. Ultimately, the question of whether John Wick 5 should be made depends on prioritizing the long-term health and success of the franchise over immediate gains. Instead of focusing solely on John Wick 5, let's consider alternative ways to continue expanding the rich and engaging world of John Wick and preserving its legacy.